Friday, June 20, 2008
Style; Take II
In the peer review portion of this course, personalities were certainly apparent in the papers I read. Putting that aside, there was an objective to be met for each of the assignments. There were varied requirements that were given. This was the writing "style" that needed to be followed. Style is not personal; it is more of a guideline.
We learned in the readings of Williams and of Strunk and White that there are some rules of grammar and good writing that cannot be avoided. We also learned that some of these rules have evolved over time and become optional. There are more informal styles that can be used when you are writing in a blog or sending an email. In our most recent assignment, we learned that there are certain styles that are appropriate to use when you are writing on a website. All of these things are not "personal" style; they are rules and guidelines that society follows in writing.
Wednesday, June 18, 2008
The Important Web Rule
It is also very important that the first page of your website identifies what the website is all about. People want to know right away if the website will have what they are looking for. Lynch & Horton's, "Web Style Guide" advises, "Talk to the people who make up your target audience, put yourself in their shoes, and make the items and services they want the most prominent items on the home page." We were instructed to do this for this assignment and it makes sense. Our home pages only have a brief introduction to what our sites are about and everything else can be accessed through the portfolio link we were asked to create.
While these two things appear to be very simple, and perhaps even elementary, they are both very important to having an organized website that people will actually look at. Lynch & Horton say, "Although people will notice the graphic design of your Web pages right away, the overall organization of the site will have the greatest impact on their experience" (Web Style Guide).
Saturday, June 14, 2008
Connecting Paper Style
Also correct "writing style" uses correct English. The same is true for proper "web style." Just because things are sometimes abbreviated and shorted on a web site for simplicity, this does not mean that proper grammar usage should be abandoned. This is also true with punctuation. Text on a website should be punctuated correctly, just as if you were writing a paper for an English course.
When you are writing a paper, you should introduce your topic in your first paragraph. This is your thesis statement. The same thing goes for a website. People want to know right away what your site is all about; they don't want to have to go to a second page or to read too far into the first page to figure out if the website they have opened will be useful for them.
There are also many differences in "web style" writing versus every day "writing style." When you are writing text for a web site, you should keep your sentences short. People who are visiting a website are looking to read information quickly and are taking only a short time to digest this information. This does not always apply in every day writing. It is not always possible to keep sentence short when you are a writing a paper for a class or even in a personal letter or an email.
There are both similarities and differences when writing for a website versus everyday writing style. Whether designing a website or maintaining a website, attention should be paid to both the similarities and the differences for maximum clarity for your website audience.
Friday, June 6, 2008
McCloud Part II
Tuesday, June 3, 2008
McCloud #1
In this comic, the man and woman could be any man and woman. They are simply outlines of male and female faces. The characters are intentionally drawn with no identifying characteristics. McCloud writes, “…when you look at a photo or realistic drawing of a case—you see it as the face of another. But when you enter the world of the cartoon—you see yourself” (McCloud 36). By not identifying a specific character, the reader is able to better identify and place themselves in the situation, either as the male or the female character.
In frames four and five of the comic, McCloud bridges the two frames together by drawing flowers in the “gutter” between the two frames. The gutter is the space between the two frames. This is normally where the mystery of what happens between the frames is up to the reader’s imagination. He says, “Here in the limbo of the gutter, human imagination takes two separate images and transforms them into a single idea” (McCloud 66). In this particular instance, McCloud is taking that the imagination away from the reader and letting them know that the man handed the woman flowers.
In frame 23, McCloud uses lines jutting out around the man’s face to show that his character is becoming distressed. There is nothing in the writing that would indicate his distress, but the jutting lines are a symbol of his distress and are just something I recognized without being told that with words. McCloud writes, “If enough artists begin using the symbol, it will enter the language for good—as many have through the years” (McCloud 129). This is obviously a symbol that has caught on and is easily recognized.
The reading of Understanding Comics made the interpretation of the comic I read much easier and interesting.
Thursday, May 22, 2008
What Do Others Think?
Wednesday, May 21, 2008
Comparing Strunk and White with Williams
In my previous blog entry discussing William Strunk and E.B. White’s book, The Elements of Style, I talked about how Strunk and White explain the hard-fast rules for the use of “who” vs. “whom.” They explain how the words are used reflective of what pronoun they are referencing. There is no talk of this being an option; it is simply what is the proper usage is for the words (Strunk 11).
In Joseph William’s book, Style: Toward Clarity and Grace, he also talks about the rules for the use of “who” vs. “whom.” He gives the same rules Strunk and White, and he also gives examples of the correct usage. The difference between two books is that in William’s book, he prefaces the rules with the word “optional.” He gives examples of the misuse of the words by famous writers and acknowledges that the breaking of this rule is rarely noticed anymore (Williams 186). My favorite sentence that he writes with regard to this rule is, “Whom is a small but distinct flag of conscious correctness, especially with the whom is in fact wrong” (Williams 187). Many writers try to use the word “whom” to make something sound more formal, more grammatically correct. What usually happens is that they use it incorrectly.
Strunk & White discuss syllabication in their book (Strunk 38). I did not find any reference to this type of technical style rule in William’s book. Style: Toward Clarity and Grace does not have the detailed, hard-fast, rules that The Elements of Style has.
Strunk and White wrote a whole section of their book on “Misused Words and Expressions (Strunk 39-65). Williams does not talk much about the misuse of words. He gives a list of what he calls, “real rules” (Williams 180). However, he also writes this wonderful paragraph that sums up for me how he really feels about writing rules in general:
The facts of the matter are these: a few especially fastidious
writers and editors try to honor and enforce every rule of usage;
most careful writers observe fewer; and there are a few writers
and editors who know all the rules, but who also know that not
all of them are worth observing and enforcing, and that they should
observe other rules only on certain occasions. (Williams 178)
I found the Strunk and White book to be a better “tool” to use when you are unclear about the hard-fast rules of writing. I think that William’s book is much more realistic in letting you know how to apply the hard-fast rules to today’s writing.
Friday, May 16, 2008
Revising With Williams
Students having the proven academic potential to succeed are welcome to attend
The first paragraph is from the EMU catalog page, The Undergraduate Experience-Admissions. The second paragraph is my revision of the original. The first problem I addressed in the EMU paragraph was with clarity. In the first sentence, it took me a couple of reads to figure out that the students were the subjects of the sentence. By moving them to the front of the sentence and making the subjects of the verb “attend” involved in the action, the purpose of the sentence is immediately clearer. Joseph Williams suggests this in his book, Style (Williams 43).
The next problem I addressed was the cohesion between sentences. The EMU paragraph was made up of two very long sentences that did not flow together well. I broke up the sentences to make shorter, clearer sentences that flowed from one to the other using words from the previous sentence.
Thursday, May 15, 2008
Strunk & White, Part 1
In William Strunk and E.B. White’s, The Elements of Style, I found many answers to rules that I question each and every time I write a paper. This book should be given to every high school student as a graduation present. In fact, my oldest daughter is graduating in two weeks. She might be horrified to find a copy of this book wrapped up as a gift, but I think she would be happy when she wrote her first paper in September.
There are a lot of grammar and style rules that you learn at a young age that aren’t used often and don’t, consequently, stick with you. I honestly don’t remember ever learning the proper rule for “who” and “whom.” If I did, it was back in junior high—back when they called middle school junior high. All in all, the first chapter of the book is a nice refresher course in grammar and is a good idea to read at least once a semester. Sometimes you know the rules, but they evade you when you are in the heart of a writing project. I found that the first three chapters of Shrunk and White were the most helpful and up-to-date.
Care less. The dismissive “I couldn’t care less” is often
used with the shortened “not” mistakenly (and mysteriously)
omitted: “I could care less.” The error destroys the meaning of
the sentence and is careless indeed. (Strunk 42)
I have always used “I could care less.” I believe that, through time, this phrase has come to mean exactly what “I couldn’t care less” meant originally.
One other “misused” word, which I found the author’s perspective quite awkward on, was the one for the word “data.” The book suggests that instead of saying, “the data is,” you should say, “these data are” (Strunk 44). If I was talking about a collection of data, I would treat the word as if it was a singular item, even if it was comprised of many things.
It is my opinion that there are a lot of instances in this book where these “rules” about word usage are up for individual interpretation and where they are just the author’s preference. Language evolves with cultural changes. Some grammar that was not “proper” twenty-five years ago is now acceptable. Grammar rules change. I know that, in my lifetime, I have seen the comma come and go at least three times, before and, in a series of three or more terms.
Friday, May 9, 2008
My Writing Technology Project
"It is a truth universally acknowledged, that single man in possession of a good fortune, must be in want of a wife." Jane Austen. Pride and Prejudice, first line.
I spent hours today trying to figure out a writing technology I could "invent" without using anything that was store-bought or man-made. I tried to crush dandelions into a paste to write with; I thought about writing on my 18-year old's back. It was literally giving me a headache. Finally, I decided that I would go all "cave man." I found a stick in the back of my yard and I used a store-bought lighter (there was no time to rub two sticks together) to light the tip. I found two pieces of wood in my garage and I painstakingly alternated between lighting the tip of the stick on fire and forming the letters on the pieces of wood. (I'm actually not sure if cave men ever even wrote anything).
When I was considering the portability of my writing project, I thought about Manguel's essay and the evolution of the book. Barron's essay made me think of how grateful I am for the technology of today's writing utensil's that I can go to my local Walgreen's and buy. I do not think I would have enjoyed living in the time of the inkwell.
Manguel and Barron
Monday, May 5, 2008
What is Style?
A casual writing style is usually acceptable for in-class writing assignments. Personal emails and blog postings are often written in a style that is not always grammatically correct but is acceptable because of the format it is in. A professional email is usually casual in style but should always contain proper grammar. Writing style is a reflection of a writer's personality, work ethic, and many times, level of education.
Welcome
Welcome to my blog! My name is Julie Berger and I am a senior majoring in Language, Literature and Writing. I am a mother of three beautiful children, Lauren (18), Robert (14) and Lucy (7). I have returned to EMU and work after taking a long hiatus to raise my children. I love to read (this is what lead me to my major decision) and to garden. I've recently discovered that I am highly amused by silly comedy (i.e. "Superbad"). I love going out to eat and just being with my children and my friends. My life isn't very exciting, but it works for me.